Superman: Red Son
Writer: Mark Millar
Pencillers: Dave Johnson & Killian Plunkett
Inkers: Andrew Robinson & Walden Wong
Colorist: Paul Mounts
Letterer: Ken Lopez
Reviewed for Raging Bullets: BulletPoints by Omri Spirman
Red Son: Finally an
answer to the ultimate “What if?” question: What would have
happened had Kal-El’s spaceship landed twelve hours later,
crashing into the USSR?
To distinguish
this review from my previous two, I’ve decided to make this one
with the least spoilers as possible. Though this results in a
shorter and not so deep examination, we’ll see how it goes.
Red Son examines
what would have happened had Superman’s “Truth, Justice and the
American Way” really been “Stalin, Socialism and the
International expansion of the Warsaw Pact.” It is a tale of
Superman growing up in rural USSR, and how different the world
would have been for that. A simple enough premise – come to
think about it, yet no one tackled this idea before this story’s
release in 2003. Writers avoided this story for fear that their
stories simply degenerate into communism vs. democracy plots,
which is not the intended focus of this tale. In Red Son,
Millar gives us a politically inclined Superman who sticks to
his ideals without defecting to the East, as was expected had
this become a story of ideologies. Despite the difference in
political systems, all Superman wants is justice, equality and
peace, so some things never change, growing- up environment non
withstanding. So to reiterate – this Elseworlds story is one of
Superman growing up under a different environment, which just
happens to be communism. The story is not one of political
supremacy nor is it one of lost causes. It is simply a
re-imagined universe, with many familiar elements seen under new
lights, and a final realization that some things will never
change.
The first
chapter, Red Son Rising, is about Superman’s growing convictions
about his place in the world and the USSR specifically, while at
the other end of the globe, Luthor’s increasing hatred towards
the new Russian superweapon. We are introduced to a new Lois
Lane, married to Luthor given Superman’s absent influence, a
government agent Jimmy Olsen, Perry White and even an elder
Martha Kent. Though the characters seem familiar, this new
universe’s circumstances have shaped them to be different people
– except perhaps Luthor. Easter eggs galore in this issue with
tributes to the first Superman cover, an imaginary novel about
Lois Luthor and Superman being lovers, and Stalin – the Man of
Steel (fitting name if you ask me). In the process of finding
his identity, Superman forges an alliance with Princess Diana,
steals Pyotr Roslov’s (Pete Ross’s) light (sound familiar?) and
becomes Stalin’s confidant. With the appearance of a young
Batman, a battle with a Luthor- created Bizarro and a fateful
meeting with childhood friend Lana Lazarenko (Lana Lang ring any
bells?), the issue ends with Superman finally deciding what he
should do about his future.
Red Son Ascent,
the second issue, catches up with us several years later. The
globe is united under Superman’s soviet banner, and only the
United States (whatever states are left and have not seceded)
and Chile (my native country! Yay!) remain independent,
capitalist, struggling economies. Superman’s enemies are now
stronger and more organized, spearheaded externally by Luthor’s
constant attempts and internally by a terrorist Batman, the
rivalry bearing a strong resemblance to Frank Miller’s DKR and
DK2. After several confrontations with both, Superman loses his
allies, makes new enemies and discovers the bitter truth of
xenophobia. Hints towards his downfall and going over the edge
begin to appear, and a fortress of solitude is built, showing
his ever-growing distance from humanity.
Red Son Setting
is, as its title suggests, the dusk of the child born under a
red sun. Superman has turned into a dictator, with no less than
Braniac by his side. But every dusk is a dawn for someone else,
and Luthor’s presidency in the US begins to work miracles
socially, scientifically and economically. Feeling threatened
and pushed to the decision by Braniac, general war breaks
between the two nations in what becomes a war of DC legends,
with Amazon squads, Green Lantern Corps, Superman, Braniac,
Luthor’s supersoldiers (Parasite, Doomsday, Metallo, Livewire,
Chemo) and more. But just as the tide is turned and the battle
is virtually won, one side comes to a realization, Braniac goes
renegade becoming a third party in the battle, and Superman is
faced with the ultimate decision his whole life had just summed
up to. Though this ending was a little too fast paced to my
taste, the epilogue more than makes up for it. I really don’t
want to ruin the epilogue so all I’ll say is that it examines
what happened ‘x’ time after this battle: ‘x’ first being days,
then years, then decades and eventually a billion years into the
future, setting the stage for yet a new beginning and a new
dawn.
Story: 4/5 – A long awaited story finally given its due. A tale of this scope had so many places where it could have gone wrong, yet Millar manages to keep it on track and avoid the political downfall altogether. Very good flow, and SO MANY easter eggs peppered throughout the issues. I even went and bought a second trade, to which I started attaching sticky flags so I could find those nods, tributes and jokes later. Good, solid story, starring a revamped DCU.
Art: 4/5 – Each of the issues has its an overall tone. To further create that, the art team gave each issue an underlying color. Just like today’s Green Lantern books are 80% green, the first issue of this story is mainly red – symbolizing Superman’s upbringing, the second is a dark, foreboding gray – stemming from Batman’s influence, and the third is green, showing growth, evolution and change.
Another place where the art shined is with the newly designed characters. These are well thought out and designed, especially the extreme- winter-clad batman. Overall good art that supports the plot. Nothing spectacular, but still good.
Overall:
4/5 – Red Son definitely stands up to its premise. A
political commentary without taking sides, a social
commentary without pointing blame. The story of Superman
going rogue through perfectly legal means, just as he had
done before in Superman: King of the World or what would
have happened had Diana’s plan in Kingdom Come gone to
fruition. This is the story of the Luthor- Superman rivalry
that will always continue whatever alternate universe they
may be in. The story of the dawn, zenith and dusk of a man
born under a red sun and of the red son himself. A great
read for dc-versed and new readers alike.